| Preservation of Recognizability |
3 |
Maintains recognizable elements of the original piano work and its character. (3) |
Mostly recognizable, with minor deviations. (2) |
Somewhat recognizable, but major elements are altered or lost. (1) |
Unrecognizable as the original work. (0) |
| Effective Adaptation for Woodwinds |
3 |
Demonstrates a thorough understanding of wind instrument capabilities and idiomatic writing. (3) |
Adequately adapted for woodwinds but includes minor issues. (2) |
Limited understanding of wind instruments, with significant unplayable sections. (1) |
Not adapted for woodwinds; a direct transcription of the piano score. (0) |
| Choice of Work and Justification |
2 |
The chosen work is highly suitable for woodwind or reed quintet, and the justification is thorough and clear. (2) |
The chosen work is suitable but lacks detail in justification. (1.5) |
The chosen work is somewhat unsuitable, with limited justification. (1) |
The chosen work is unsuitable or justification is missing. (0) |
| Quality of Deliverables |
2 |
All deliverables are submitted, well-organized, and error-free. (2) |
Deliverables are submitted but contain minor errors. (1) |
One or more required deliverables are missing or poorly executed. (0.5) |
No deliverables submitted. (0) |
